Module 2: Videos and Article Review
The key concept I learned in the first video, "Aesthetics: Philosophy of the Arts", was that aesthetics and art are much different, when in reality many people think they are basically the same thing. The philosophers all explained their outlooks and theories on aesthetics, which made it clear the aesthetic and art are completely different. Every human brain thinks of aesthetics in their own way. Art is seen similar to many people, but aesthetic is what draws people in based off of their preferences. The same connection is for music, or plays, or even poetry. Hearing the ideas from each philosopher and speaker, help understand the reasoning for the known, yet unknown, aspects of aesthetics to art. The second video drew more of my attention with speaker number two, Ramachandran, and his ideas about Indian aesthetic versus Greek. From what history has taught us, Greek sculptures of extremely muscular men are more "pleasing" to the eye than the Indian sculptures that depict how real men look, with a little bit of body fat in areas that are completely normal. The fact that sculptors knew to make the Greek male sculptures muscular, shows that they understood aesthetics and how to please the viewers. In India, even if their sculptures were very humanistic, or realistic, people did not seem aesthetically pleased by it, and that proves that people have their own idea of "beauty" in aesthetics. Yes, people see pleasing aspects in the Greek sculptures, but they also see the actual human body that they are attracted to in real life, so how do we know what is "beauty" in art, and not in real life? The CNN article talks about the aesthetics that animals can see, also. The seagull experiment stood out to me because it is interesting to know that not only are humans attracted to more intense or abstract versions of reality, but animals are too. Seagulls like to see a yellow beak with a red stripe on it, to think it is their mother, but they actually love to see the exaggerated version which would be multiple red stripes. Our brains register something that we know we have seen before, even if it is slightly distorted.
Francis Hutchesons philosophy of aesthetics is the most important to me. His idea that beauty and harmony are brought together in the soul by a work of art, tells that aesthetic and art are connected internally. A person can feel happiness and strong emotion from a work of art, but also strong sad emotions from a work of art. I believe he is trying to say that a good work of art only applies to one individuals opinion, versus a group of people who may not agree with each other. Aesthetics are everywhere, but if one person finds something more aesthetically pleasing than another, or the feeling of harmony, than the opinions on specific works of art are stronger than the message the art, in some cases. In other cases.
The most interesting fact from Changeux's lecture was the psychology of conscious versus non conscious processes in the brain. He talked about whether a person can consciously see a painting, while unconsciously seeing the underlying meaning to a painting, or even the shadows and small aspects, or if they can only consciously see paint on canvas. This stood out to me because people still study this today, and people try to force themselves to understand the deeper meaning in most works of art. Ramachandran's connection to aesthetics and science was very interesting. He used the example of dots and dots moving, creating a whole figure that our eyes can see, even though it is not an actual representation to something we see every day. He should the picture of all of the still dots on the screen, ad then some of the dots moved, forming a smiley face. Obviously, we have never really seen a person with that face and lack of features, but we know what it is because our brains tell us to remember based off of experiences and science.
The videos relate to the readings in the book in many ways. One of the main connections I found was the tasks that artists use to create art and their reasoning, and the lecture videos talking about why a person creates art work in a specific way, like the Indian sculptures versus the Greek sculptures. The videos talked about why things like sculptures, paintings, plays, and languages are all connected to specific cultures, and so does the book. The book connects to these aspects with the themes in chapter three. Each theme is basically a very similar technique compared to another, so it shows that each theme may rely on the cultural background and the meaning behind it. The first video brought up many good points about the philosophy of art and aesthetic, that can also be found all within the book.
I feel as if the first film was really helpful, hearing the philosophies and speakers talk about each philosopher. The second video was more difficult to understand exactly what they were trying to get to, but the second speaker really caught my attention with a few of his points of view on cultural art. The article was also less helpful than the textbook, but I did enjoy reading about how lines in a drawing are not actually in real life, but we know what the drawing is because our brain is so conditioned to what we see every day. It was also a nice twist to learn about animals and their use of art. They all added more depth to my understandings in the book because of each connection to art and aesthetics, but also the connections to just being able to create art in general. The study of the brain is much more complicated than the study of art, yet they are so connected it is almost hard to not group the two categories together. The textbook connected everything back to art and being human, which is the main objectives of the videos and the CNN article.
-Sara
Francis Hutchesons philosophy of aesthetics is the most important to me. His idea that beauty and harmony are brought together in the soul by a work of art, tells that aesthetic and art are connected internally. A person can feel happiness and strong emotion from a work of art, but also strong sad emotions from a work of art. I believe he is trying to say that a good work of art only applies to one individuals opinion, versus a group of people who may not agree with each other. Aesthetics are everywhere, but if one person finds something more aesthetically pleasing than another, or the feeling of harmony, than the opinions on specific works of art are stronger than the message the art, in some cases. In other cases.
The most interesting fact from Changeux's lecture was the psychology of conscious versus non conscious processes in the brain. He talked about whether a person can consciously see a painting, while unconsciously seeing the underlying meaning to a painting, or even the shadows and small aspects, or if they can only consciously see paint on canvas. This stood out to me because people still study this today, and people try to force themselves to understand the deeper meaning in most works of art. Ramachandran's connection to aesthetics and science was very interesting. He used the example of dots and dots moving, creating a whole figure that our eyes can see, even though it is not an actual representation to something we see every day. He should the picture of all of the still dots on the screen, ad then some of the dots moved, forming a smiley face. Obviously, we have never really seen a person with that face and lack of features, but we know what it is because our brains tell us to remember based off of experiences and science.
The videos relate to the readings in the book in many ways. One of the main connections I found was the tasks that artists use to create art and their reasoning, and the lecture videos talking about why a person creates art work in a specific way, like the Indian sculptures versus the Greek sculptures. The videos talked about why things like sculptures, paintings, plays, and languages are all connected to specific cultures, and so does the book. The book connects to these aspects with the themes in chapter three. Each theme is basically a very similar technique compared to another, so it shows that each theme may rely on the cultural background and the meaning behind it. The first video brought up many good points about the philosophy of art and aesthetic, that can also be found all within the book.
I feel as if the first film was really helpful, hearing the philosophies and speakers talk about each philosopher. The second video was more difficult to understand exactly what they were trying to get to, but the second speaker really caught my attention with a few of his points of view on cultural art. The article was also less helpful than the textbook, but I did enjoy reading about how lines in a drawing are not actually in real life, but we know what the drawing is because our brain is so conditioned to what we see every day. It was also a nice twist to learn about animals and their use of art. They all added more depth to my understandings in the book because of each connection to art and aesthetics, but also the connections to just being able to create art in general. The study of the brain is much more complicated than the study of art, yet they are so connected it is almost hard to not group the two categories together. The textbook connected everything back to art and being human, which is the main objectives of the videos and the CNN article.
-Sara
Comments
Post a Comment